Skip to Content

Spot something we can improve? Use the feedback link — we read every note.

The Reading Dr. logo

THE READING DR.

All reading help

Growing Readers · Inference & Characters

Why Did the Character Do That? Teaching Kids to Read Between the Lines

Reading tests constantly ask why a character did something — a question about inference. Build that skill through everyday conversation, starting tonight.

Character silhouettes on an open book examined with a magnifying glass

A huge share of reading comprehension questions are really one question in disguise: Why did the character do that?

Answering it takes inference — using what the text shows to reason about what it doesn't say outright. And unlike decoding, this is a skill you can practice at the dinner table, in the car, anywhere — because people are characters too.

What the reader is actually doing

To infer why a character behaved a certain way, a reader has to piece together three kinds of clues the author leaves:

  • Actions — and just as importantly, inactions (what the character chose not to do)
  • Spoken words — and what was left unsaid
  • Body language — reactions, expressions, silence

Good readers combine those clues with their own life experience to reach a conclusion the text never states. That's inference.

Practice with the characters in your house

Try this with a sibling or family member:

Scenario: Judy comes home from school crying. Ask: Why do you think Judy is upset? She hasn't told us — so you'd have to guess. Reasonable answer: She had a bad day at school, or something happened on the way home.

That is a reading test question — the exact kind shows up as: "Was Judy happy or sad when she came home from school in Chapter 3? How do you know?"

A strong answer sounds like: "Judy was sad, because she was crying when she got home — and when I cry, I'm usually sad." Notice what makes it strong: the child states a conclusion and the evidence behind it, connecting the character's behavior to their own experience.

The magic question: "How do you know?"

"How do you know?" appears on reading tests constantly — and children who can't explain their answers often receive only partial credit, even when the answer itself is right. A habit of answering it at home, every day, is the difference.

So make it a reflex. When your child guesses why a family member is grumpy, or predicts what happens next in a TV show, ask the follow-up every time: "How do you know?" Play the game with movies and shows — pause, guess, defend the guess. It feels like fun. It's inference practice.

Level up: character traits

Test questions also ask children to identify character traits — brave, honest, selfish, loyal. A simple routine builds this vocabulary:

  1. Learn what each trait means (a handful at a time).
  2. Describe real family members using those traits — "What trait describes Grandpa? Why?"
  3. Defend the choice with "How do you know?"

Then the test version — "Name two character traits that describe the main character, using evidence from the story" — is just the dinner-table game in costume.

Start early

Even first and second graders can do this. The earlier a child learns that good readers back up every answer with evidence, the better prepared they are for every reading test to come.

Let your child try it right now

Reading between the lines is a skill — and this game drills it directly. Sit with your child and press play — no sign-up, no email needed.

Play a reading game

Reviewed by The Reading Doctor team · 2018-11-29

© 2026 The Reading Dr. — Evidence-based PreK–6 reading interventions. Privacy Policy · For Schools & Districts

Session security: you're automatically logged out after 20 minutes of inactivity to protect student data (FERPA/COPPA).